What are Reimbursement Claims?
During the course of a marriage, spouses will often contribute separate property (such as an inheritance or funds from an account created prior to marriage) to a community asset (such as the downpayment on a home made following the date of marriage). A “Reimbursement Claim” is an attempt for one estate (often the separate estate of one of the spouses) to recover money spent on another (frequently the community estate). When this type of cross-estate spending occurs, separate and community assets may become “commingled,” opening the possibility of reimbursement claims.
How to Win a Reimbursement Claim
Although property division and reimbursements within a divorce are most frequently settled at mediation, about 5% of cases will go before a judge or a jury instead. Either way, here are some steps you will need to complete along the process:
Step 1 – Complete an Inventory
This crucial first step involves identifying all assets and liabilities through a Sworn Inventory & Appraisement. This document will include everything from stocks and retirement accounts to debts and pets. Courts require that parties exchange a property inventory prior to trial. In most cases, parties, with the help of their attorneys, will format this inventory into a spreadsheet.
Step 2 – Identify Community Property
After listing assets on an inventory, one must identify all community property. This can be accomplished by identifying property that was acquired during the course of the marriage, and listing it in a “community” column.
Step 3 – Identify Your Separate Property
After listing and identifying all community property, the same must be done for separate property. Property is separate if it meets any of the following standards:
- acquired prior to the date of marriage,
- is a gift,
- is an inheritance or,
- is a monetary recovery from a personal injury
Step 4 – List any Reimbursement Claims
At this point, one can list reimbursement claims. For example, one could cite money from an inheritance used for a down payment on a home acquired during the marriage.
Step 5 – Submit a Proposed Property Division
After the above steps have been completed, it is prudent to have a serious discussion with an attorney regarding what property you would like to keep and what property you would be willing to divide. Then, you will indicate your offers on a spreadsheet called a proposed property division.
Your inventory may look something like this:
|Community Value||To Wife||To Husband|
|1234 Wilson Rd. Austin, Texas
Mortgage *0981 ($87,000)
|Cash & Accounts w/ Financial Institutions|
|Chase Bank *4455 (H)||$10,000||$0||$10,000|
|Bank of America *7777 (W)||$3,000||$3,000||$0|
|Fidelity 401(k) *8266||$230,000||$115,000||$115,000|
|Motor Vehicles, Boats|
|2010 WG Explorer GT
|2002 WG Motorcycle
|Jake Gilbreath Credit Card *9-1145||(-2,000)||($2,000)|
|Attorney Fees of Wife||TBD||X|
|Attorney Fees of Husband||TBD||X|
|Separate Property of Wife|
|Gift Money Received from Father (*Spent on home rennovations)||$65,000||$65,000|
|Separate Property of Husband|
|Inheritance from H’s Mother (Spent on Down Payment for Home)||$102,000||$102,000|
|Reimbursement Claims of Wife|
|Reimbursement Claims of Husband|
The Divestment of Separate Property
A court cannot divide separate property during a divorce. However, it falls upon each party to demonstrate that an asset is their separate property through “clear and convincing evidence.” This high legal standard requires an experienced attorney to demonstrate adequately. In particularly complicated situations, your attorney may suggest that you hire a forensic accountant to conduct a process called tracing. During this process, an accountant will compile a report which demonstrates the provenance of your separate property assets through “clear and convincing evidence,” proving that they are gifts, inheritances, products of a medical settlement, or were owned prior to the marriage.
You should consult with an experienced attorney who guide you and even help you gather the evidence that you’ll need.